Office of Sustainability Plans to Buy Millions in Carbon Offsets: Local Environmental Group Says, “That’s Completely Wrong”
by P.D. Lesko
In a paper dated Nov. 18 and titled “The Climate Case Against Carbon Offsets,” the local environmental group Washtenaw350 writes Ann Arbor should focus on eliminating its own emissions rather than paying others to reduce theirs.
In July 2026, the Ann Arbor Independent reported that the City’s Office of Sustainability and Innovation (OSI) was going to fail to meet its goal of zero carbon emissions by 2030. On the OSI Dashboard, it says, “A2ZERO Goal: 100% of Citywide Greenhouse Gases will be eliminated or offset by 2030.” The goal of carbon neutrality and zero emissions by 2030 is clearly out of reach, according to the OSI Greenhouse Gas Emissions Dashboard. Dr. Missy Stults, who leads OSI and its 41 employees told the A2Indy, “I don’t think it’s accurate to say we aren’t going to meet our goal by 2030. That’s why we will be launching a community conversation and engagement series this summer around offsets. In this way, we hope to really engage stakeholders in thinking about what offsets are/can be, what we value the most when we think about offsets (aka, what characteristics do we want in our offsets), and also have conversations about how we will have to continue doing the work of reducing local emissions directly so that we minimize (and reduce) the amount of offsets we’ll use as we move this work forward.”
The cost of offsetting carbon emissions ranges from $1 to over $500 per metric ton of carbon dioxide equivalent, heavily depending on whether you choose cheap renewable energy credits, nature-based forestry projects, or expensive high-tech permanent removals.
From the City’s A2Zero Plan, “Offsets are only used to close the greenhouse gas emissions gap between what we are able to do locally and what needs to be offset to achieve our goal of carbon neutrality by 2030.” The Plan projects spending $9.4 million ($32 per metric ton) to offset a projected gap of 13.6 percent of emissions not reduced by local programs and services by 2030. In 2028, the A2Zero Plan says Ann Arbor will “undertake first greenhouse gas emissions offset purchase and continue as needed.”
Ann Arbor is presently generating 1.8 metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions above its stated 2030 goal (zero); the gap between what Ann Arbor has achieved thus far and zero emissions is nowhere near the modest 13.6 percent gap (298,500 metric tons of carbon dioxide) predicted in the A2Zero Plan. The gap is a multiple of 13.6 percent and, as such, offsets would cost a multiple of the projected $9.4 million, an amount that is almost 85 percent of the total $11.3 million in revenue city officials project will be generated by the Climate Action Millage in 2027.
Lauren Sargent is a co-founder of Washtenaw 350. She told MLive, “Carbon offsets are a false climate solution. The idea that we’ve done all we can to reduce our emissions and now must pay others to reduce theirs is completely wrong. There is much more we can do here that we’re not doing.”
Dr. Stults was asked how many metric tons of carbon dioxide she predicted would need to be offset beginning in 2028, because the 13.6 percent “gap” figure of 298,500 metric tons in the A2Zero Plan is clearly off the mark. She said: “Unfortunately, I cannot answer it yet. We are still waiting on data from multiple sources (e.g., Google EIE, DTE, WATS) just to get our 2025 inventory complete. We also need data on future planning and projections (e.g., Integrated Resource Plans from our utilities, EIA projections) so we can figure out what emissions are likely to look like in 2030 to base decision making on. This is all part of the work we are doing behind the scenes as part of the offset work.”
OSI’s Dashboard shows a 10 percent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions between 2022-2024, leaving total greenhouse gas emissions in Ann Arbor standing at 1.8 million metric tons. Assuming another 15 percent reduction in Ann Arbor’s greenhouse gas emissions between 2024-2027, Dr. Stults will still be left with 1.53 metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions to offset with taxpayer funds used to purchase carbon credits. At a cost of $32 per metric ton, as proposed in the most recent A2Zero Plan, offsetting 1.53 million metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions would cost Ann Arbor taxpayers $48.9 million in 2028, plus the cost of the Climate Change Millage, a total somewhere north of $60.9 million. The City’s 2027 General Fund stands at $170 million, including a $34.5 million budget for police and a $21.3 million budget for firefighters.
Dr. Stults said in an email, “I’m looking forward to engaging with the public on this topic so we can, together, decide what Ann Arbor wants its offsets to look like.” The City’s focus is on asking residents to choose between different kinds of offsets to purchase with tax dollars.
Ken Garber, an environmental reporter who wrote the Washtenaw350 position paper, told MLive that offsetting sends the wrong message to the market. Garber also said asking residents to choose which carbon offsets to purchase is a false choice. Instead, the Washtenaw350 group argues in its paper, the question should be whether Ann Arbor should choose to purchase offsets at all.
Dr. Stults puts the choice as purchasing carbon offsets to meet Ann Arbor’s 2030 carbon zero goal, or delaying the 2030 goal. There has been no discussion on City Council about the fact that Dr. Stults and OSI project that despite their work and millions of tax dollars Ann Arbor will miss virtually every sustainability goal set when the Climate Action Millage was passed by residents in 2022. “The millage will raise around $140-$150 million over its life. [W]e leverage the millage (or have historically and plan to in the future) as match for grant funding. Of course, cuts in federal programs, staffing, and initiatives are having a local impact but thanks to the millage, we are able to keep programs moving (just not as fast as desired),” explained Dr. Stults.
Rita Mitchell, another co-founder of the Washtenaw350 group, wants the timeline for the presentation to City Council to approve the offset purchases to be extended. Mitchell reportedly said, “We should extend that timeline to allow for a community discussion of both the pros and cons of offsetting. We’d be happy to work with the city to facilitate that discussion.”
The Kleinman Center for Energy Policy is a non-partisan nonprofit that supports transitions to sustainable energy. The Center researches carbon offset market fraud. In 2024, the Center published a piece which examined what it called the “crisis of confidence” in the carbon offset market.
“Last year, an investigation by the Guardian and Corporate Accountability found that most of the world’s largest carbon dioxide offset projects failed to deliver promised climate benefits. The report is among several questioning the integrity and effectiveness of voluntary carbon offset programs in achieving net-zero emissions,” said Kleinman Center Senior Fellow Danny Cullenward.
Cullenward said, “This [carbon offset] market is relatively opaque. There is very little public transparency. Time and time again, when people dig into these opaque systems, they find that most of the money isn’t actually going to the landowners and the local communities. It’s going to all of the industry participants, from the consultants who help prepare the paperwork, to the verifiers who check in on this, to the brokers who buy and sell these activities. Most of the money doesn’t actually go to the end use, the sort of claimed-worthy climate project. A lot of it ends up in the hands of the intermediaries.”
Danny Cullenward says, “I think we need to move away from offsetting. Don’t make the claim that your offset reductions are the same as CO2 emissions. They’re not. Stop doing it.
Washtenaw 350 is the local chapter of 350.org, an international nonprofit that aims to end the use of fossil fuels. According to the group’s website, “350 refers to 350 parts per million — the maximum level of carbon (CO2) in the atmosphere safe for people and the planet.”


Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.