After 2 Months in Office, Gov. Rick Snyder’s Approval Rating Tanks

Newspaper editorialists and political pundits have praised Governor Rick Snyder for not attacking Michigan’s public-sector union employees, or like Wisconsin’s Governor, trying to restrict collective bargaining on the part of public-sector unions. In a February 27, 2011 piece published in the Macomb Daily, we read: “Don’t expect the battle over the collective bargaining rights of state workers to blaze a trail through Michigan.”

Snyder told the Associated Press in late-February that, “he’s had a good dialogue with labor unions since taking office and wants to work with public employee unions to seek concessions he says are needed to balance the state budget….I respect the other governors, clearly, but as a practical matter I think we’ve already made our decision that there’s a different way of doing things.”

Reporter Nathan Bomey at AnnArbor.com posted a CliffsNotes piece based on reporting from The Detroit News in December 2010 titled, “Targeting public employees’ collective bargaining rights unlikely, Snyder says.” In that piece we read, “Michigan Gov.-elect Rick Snyder, who has indicated that he believes public employee compensation cuts are necessary to stabilize Michigan’s budget, told the Detroit News in an interview that he doesn’t think it’s necessary to restrict public employees’ collective bargaining rights.”

Today, I received a robo-call poll from a company reaching out on behalf of Governor Rick Snyder. I was asked some pretty interesting questions, the first of which was:

1.  Would you support Michigan becoming a work-for-hire state?

Would I? No. Do I believe Rick Snyder chose a Lt. Governor Calley, a politico who favors making Michigan a work-for-hire state, in order to seriously explore the idea of doing so? Yes.

Guess what? Democrats and Independents who thought “Ann Arbor” businessman Rick Snyder would be a different kind of Republican are having serious buyer’s remorse.

According to a poll reported on today, and conducted by the Detroit Free Press:

“The huge popularity Snyder had in polls taken in late January sank considerably. Forty-four percent view Snyder favorably, and 27% view him unfavorably. In January, 59% viewed him favorably and 8% unfavorably. That was after Republican Snyder’s inauguration and his well-received State of the State address. Since then, he presented his budget plan Feb. 17, which features a sweeping reduction of business taxes and higher taxes for many individuals.”

The poll of 600 Michigan residents was conducted on Monday by EPIC/MRA of Lansing. Bernie Porn works for EPIC and had this to say about the results: “Voters’ assessment of Snyder appears to have shifted quickly and sharply. The shift was most pronounced among Democrats and independents, who apparently don’t share the governor’s view that his budget and tax plan represent shared sacrifice. Snyder’s favorable rating among independents fell from 40% in January to 26%.”

Would I be A2Politico if I didn’t once again say we have lots of Ann Arbor Democrats to thank for Snyder’s success? Ann Arbor’s Democratic state Senator Rebekah Warren was positively glowing when she got to lead Snyder to the podium the evening he delivered his state of the State address. She burbled to the media about how great it will be to spread the “successes” of Ann Arbor SPARK—investigative reporting to the contrary by the Detroit Free Press and the Mackinac Center be damned. Most recently, as the Republican-controlled state Senate on March 2, 2011 began an effort to overturn new health benefits for same sex partners and others living with state employees in the state Senate, Warren, who voted against the resolution, was quoted in the Lansing State Journal as reminding stunned Democrats and Independents of Snyder’s desire to “run the state more like a business.” She argued that a “majority of Fortune 500 companies in the nation have offered domestic partner health benefits to their employees.”

Who among us is silly enough to believe when the Senate and House revoke health benefits offered to same sex partners successfully, that Governor Snyder will veto the proposal? Maybe Democratic Senator Rebekah Warren? Maybe some of the Democrats and Independents in Ann Arbor who privately gave thousands to Snyder’s campaign and voted for him?

Next question from the robo-call poll:

2. Would you support a law in Michigan that ended elective abortion?

Hell, no. If Republicans in Lansing don’t want to have abortions, they shouldn’t have them. That includes Governor Snyder and Andy Dillon.

I would favor a law that ended elective naivité of the electorate. I would be 100 percent behind a law that ended elective ignorance and the general stupidity associated with funding the campaign and voting for a conservative politician who is rich and callous enough to target poor people, threaten women’s reproductive rights, and poll 100 percent voters like me about whether he would have our support in attacking collective bargaining. I would support a move to legislate that Democrats and Independents who supported Rick Snyder get a free “Kick Me, I Supported Snyder” sign to put on their backs.

To order a sign for a friend or neighbor, call state Senator Rebekah Warren’s office in Lansing.

9 Comments
  1. rose says

    So I see there’s an interesting website out these days http://firericksnyder.org
    a site dedicated to recalling the governor. Could that really happen? I read somewhere they recall effort would need millions of signatures, but then again, a lot of people are hopping mad.
    Interesting times we live in, unfortunately.

  2. Mark Koroi says

    @Yale89:

    No, I do not believe Snyder will get his budget passed.

    Just recently State Senator Joe Hune of Hamburg Township, a rising GOP star and one of the most conservative members of the state senate , went on record to oppose taxation of pensions.

    I found it ironic the State Treasury is now controlled by Snyder appointee Andy Dillon, the same Democrat that anti-tax Republicans, led by former GOP legislator Leon Drolet, tried to recall in 2008 and commenced federal court proceedings against Dillon and Terri Land to successfully enforce their recall petitions to put the recall on the ballot. Although they lost the recall election, Dillon ally Miles Handy, Redford Township supervisor, got voted out of office due to the bad publicity he received trying to support Dillon agains being recalled. The hiring of Roger Fraser is another example of Snyder drawing on Democratic-linked individuals to staff the State Treasury and shape the taxing and spending policy of the Snyder administration.

    The success of the GOP in Michigan can be traced to their populist anti-tax platform. They secured control of the State Senate in 1983 after recalling two state senators, Philip Mastin and David Serotkin, who supported the Democratic-sponsored income tax hike of 37.5% that year.

    After the Democratic landslide in 2008 the Michigan Democratic Party and Gov. Granholm ignored populist sentiment to enact comprehensive mortgage relief to protect homeowners from losing their homes. State Senator Hansen Clarke of Detroit sponsored Senate Bill 1306 to adopt Depression-era legislation that had expired long ago to grant a 2-year moratorium against home foreclosures. Neither Granholm or the state Dems supported this bill and it died. Clarke gained a tremendous amount of positive publicity for his advocacy of this bill and ended up defeating long-term incumbent Carolyn Kilpatrick for the Democratic nomination by a wide margin – something that was unthinkable a few years earlier. Other Democratic candidates did nowhere near as well as Clarke in 2008.

    If Governor Snyder continues on a path toward unpopular fiscal policies, expect the GOP legislators in the State Senate and House to both oppose such measures. The continued success of the Michigan Republican Party and its elected officeholders depends on their adherence to populist ideals against taxation.

  3. lighthouse says

    I love the cartoon!! It’s perfect. It’s about time A2Politico had editorial cartoons. I hope you plan to have them regularly.

  4. A2 Politico says

    @John, where do you stand on this? I’ve heard that the cost:income ratio was 10:1, but find that difficult to believe. Plus, I just can’t comprehend how to place a price on seeing Michigan in the movies!! In other words, positive views of Michigan, as opposed to, say, the Time magazine year-long exposé on Detroit. There is just no downside to having Hollywood do PR for Michigan.

  5. John Dory says

    Sean:

    The film credits you are referring to has been a hot political topic for years in Michigan.

    Mitch Albom tried to vilify in his newspaper column Michigan Senate Finance Committee chair Nancy Kassis for wanting to abolish these credits and Governor Snyder has wanted to do the same with Albom in opposition once more.

    What you need to do if you feel so strongly is to lobby your elected representatives to oppose this abolition of these incentives.

  6. Sean says

    One of the things he’s trying to ax in his budget is the film credits. I was born in Saginaw and came to this state from Florida hoping to find work here as a grip or PA in the growing film industry here in Michigan, and industry that Ernst&Young says returned 6 dollars for every dollar of the $92 million average Michigan has invested since 2008 through the Incentives programs. Just by announcing the budget he’s already cost people here jobs as films have pulled out because apparently the state cannot afford it.

    If Michigan is making six dollars for every dollar invested, isn’t that GOOD for the state? Capping it at 25 million will ruin that income and send the youth here packing back outside to other states to find work and pay taxes elsewhere in the country. It’s freaking madness.

  7. Yale89 says

    @Mark as Gov. Snyder is a GOP outsider, as it were, do you think he will be able to muster the clout within the GOP to get his agenda passed? I have heard from colleagues in Lansing that the GOP members of the legislature are simply moving ahead with their own agendas. In other words, what favors does he have to call on when push comes to shove? Reading this entry and one can’t help but think that Gov. Snyder obviously has plans he kept well-hidden while he ran. My question is whether or not he has the political clout to get anything done that might endanger the political careers of the GOP members whom he (in theory) leads. What are your thoughts?

  8. Mark Koroi says

    We will have to wait to see if the Snyder economic recovery plan creates long-term growth and recovery. At this point polls are useless. The only approval polls that will count will be in 2014 when and if he faces re-election.

    Rick Snyder operated a venture capital firm and had close ties to GOP chairRon Weiser. I do not believe he has much sympathy for labor unions or burdensome taxes uopn businesses. He was considered an outsider in conservative GOP circles and eschewed traditional campaigning in getting elected to the GOP nomination.

    There has never been an incumbent Republican governor in Michigan that has not been returned to office by voters in my lifetime. As long as he can do a halfway decent job, te governor’s chair will be his until Jan 1, 2019.

  9. Tish says

    Amen A2Politico! I would like to create a bumper sticker that reades, “Don’t Blame Me I Voted for Bernero.”

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.