With Overtime, City Employees Increase Their Take-Home Pay by as Much as 58 Percent

Updated on 1/24/22 with comments from Council member Jeff Hayner.

by P.D. Lesko

The City of Ann Arbor currently employs approximately 840 full-time regular employees and 1,400 part-time and temporary employees. In 2020, taxpayers forked over $64 million in salaries to the city’s 2,240 employees, according to public records. That amount included $3 million in overtime pay. Of that $3 million, however, almost 60 percent of the overtime money, $1.76 million, went to just 120 of the city’s employees. One full-time city employee increased his base pay by a whopping 58 percent with overtime pay. Public records also revealed evidence of pension spiking by a number of City employees who retired in 2020. Some retirees’ pay in their final years of employment was boosted by as much as 80 percent, thus increasing lifetime pension payouts.

Fire Marshal Kathleen D. Summersgill, hired in February of 1983, earned a base salary of $104,644. In 2020, the year she retired, her gross salary ballooned to $161,415. Fire Battalion Chief Mark Edman spiked his pension even higher. In 2020, Edman’s base salary was $96,209. In his last year on the job before retirement, his pay was $174,253. The pension spiking is not confined to those in the Safety Services departments. Water Utility Supervisor III, Jeffrey Zabel, hired in 1995, was paid a base salary of $86,923. In 2020, the year Zabel retired, his salary was $120,100. The overtime pay Summersgill, Edman and Zabel received in 2020 will permanently boost their pension payouts in every year of retirement. Some labor contracts allow overtime to count toward workers’ pensions and some don’t. In Reading and Lancaster, PA for instance, union contracts forbid pension spiking.

Jim McAneny, is the executive director of Pennsylvania’s Public Employee Retirement Commission. He explains the political calculus behind spiking salaries. “If I include the money in your paycheck, I’m going to have to take it out of this year’s budget,” he said. “If I put it into the pension instead, it’s gonna be someone else’s problem down the road.”

The Ann Arbor Independent asked every member of City Council if they were aware of the problem with pension spiking. Mayor Taylor (D) has had a seat on City Council for almost 15 years and is running for re-election. However, it was Ward 1 Council member Jeff Hayner (D) who answered. Hayner said in an email, “[I was not aware] until reading your story specifically about this. I had always heard rumors of this, especially relating to public safety at U-M events. The rumor was that public city employees were assigned to U-M events, like football games, based o their seniority. The University, in some cases, compensates the City for these hours, but not at a rate that covers our future obligation in pensions. I asked about it, and was told that it had been a long-time practice, and ‘Somebody had to be assigned to the job,” so, basically, it was ok to do it. I disagreed.”

In 2013, California Gov. Jerry Brown signed into law a measure that banned pension spiking by public employees. The state’s unions representing those employees sued, but in 2020 the California Supreme Court refused to overturn the 2013 law.

Council members and the City Administrator are directly responsible for leaving the door open to pension spiking. This is because Ann Arbor’s employee union contracts are negotiated under the supervision of the Administrator then approved by City Council. Those contracts allow overtime to be used in the employees’ pension benefit formula. Springfield, IL ended this practice in 2015.

Ann Arbor taxpayers pay the pension and benefits given to the city’s 1,102 retirees. There are currently 725 active city employees participating in the City’s defined benefit pension plan, and between June 2019 and June 2020 taxpayers contributed $27.7 million to city employee pension plans. To put that amount into perspective, Ann Arbor’s 2021 budget includes spending $30.7 million on policing and $5.1 million on public services. Out of the 15.625 mills in property taxes collected for the City’s operational expenses in 2020, 1.9452 of those mills went to employee benefits.

Council member Hayner said, “One of the few successes I have had on council was in my first two years, when we had a group that took fiscal responsibility into consideration, and pension mandates and funding mechanisms were examined and improved with policy changes and budget changes. I think it’s a poor idea to allow pension spiking] to continue in any form, as not only does it undo the positive, corrective changes we have made, but it influences future budget and policy decisions, it’s like stealing from the future.”

The employees who took home the most in overtime pay include a Public Works Tech II, a Public Works Supervisor III and a Detective III. The Detective III, David L. Monroe, did not retire in 2020, but in 2018 his use of overtime to significantly hike his base pay was the subject of an article titled, “Overtime In Final Years Will Spike Ann Arbor Cop’s Lifetime Pension Payout.” Writer Tom Gantert use the Freedom of Information Act to obtain Monroe’s pay records. Gantert writes:

One Ann Arbor police detective with 31 years of experience would collect an annual pension of $126,000 if he retired this year, according to the city of Ann Arbor.

Detective David Monroe is eligible for that six-figure pension because he collected $47,491 in overtime in his final year, boosting his base pay of $93,922 to a total salary of $151,618. The overtime is not the only additional compensation police officers receive on top of overtime.

The overtime pay Monroe received in 2017 would permanently boost his pension payout by $13,495 in every year of retirement. 

Here are the employees who took home the most overtime pay in 2020. The percentage is the amount the 2020 overtime pay spiked the employee’s base salary.

City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Christopher		Foerg	7/24/20	$89,752.00	12.03%	$10,800.58	$134,848.93	Senior Officer II – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Noel		Scott	10/7/96	$97,531.20	12.09%	$11,793.60	$114,353.45	Detective III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Adam	L.	Bolgos	11/17/13	$61,443.20	12.10%	$7,434.13	$66,908.83	Water Utility Tech III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Corey	F.	Mills	1/30/06	$102,003.20	12.20%	$12,448.12	$124,115.34	Police Staff Sgt Degreed
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Amber	L.	Terry	5/15/17	$56,763.20	12.23%	$6,944.17	$61,394.97	Water Utility Tech III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Ernest	G.	Close	5/6/02	$76,291.49	12.24%	$9,336.24	$103,222.92	Driver/Operator
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Dena	C.	Waddell	11/11/96	$60,132.80	12.37%	$7,437.14	$68,548.12	Admin Assistant Lvl 4
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Taylor		Buchanan	5/18/20	$44,789.47	12.43%	$5,567.07	$36,278.54	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Rachel	A.	Weinberg	9/13/20	$39,873.60	12.50%	$4,984.02	$22,994.34	Admin Assistant Lvl 2
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Jamie	C.	Adkins	10/2/95	$91,998.40	12.50%	$11,501.43	$108,048.04	Senior Officer II – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	David	J.	Kastner	5/11/20	$49,108.80	12.52%	$6,146.32	$35,778.32	Water Utility Tech II
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Christopher	W.	Nielsen	7/8/02	$75,636.29	12.55%	$9,493.77	$98,263.60	Driver/Operator – Assoc
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Cynthia	A.	Schultz	6/15/98	$72,945.60	12.59%	$9,186.99	$93,832.35	Payroll Specialist V
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Eric	D.	Sexton	7/1/19	$45,801.60	12.59%	$5,768.62	$51,949.90	FMT-AAHC II
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Gregory	P.	Stumpmier	7/20/15	$58,177.60	12.67%	$7,368.24	$63,455.13	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Steven	B.	Dye	6/28/99	$91,998.40	12.72%	$11,701.12	$108,421.79	Senior Officer II – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Ciara	A.	Johnson	7/15/19	$55,702.40	12.97%	$7,222.50	$47,807.72	Police Officer – Assoc
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Terry	R.	Wain	10/21/19	$48,006.40	13.02%	$6,248.34	$51,198.84	Public Works Tech I – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Michael	J.	Rudolph	9/17/18	$52,599.46	13.03%	$6,856.31	$76,874.00	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kyle	R.	Weinman	8/11/14	$80,454.40	13.04%	$10,492.26	$90,948.04	Water Utility Supv IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Jonathan	A.	McDonagh	3/7/16	$79,560.00	13.07%	$10,401.31	$93,327.85	Police Officer – Assoc
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Howard	J.	Cooper IV	7/15/19	$56,950.40	13.18%	$7,503.75	$48,181.77	Police Officer – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Duane	A.	Weible	2/25/97	$72,924.80	13.18%	$9,608.86	$82,583.35	Water Utility Tech V
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Mark	R.	Luick	9/18/95	$94,768.13	13.24%	$12,547.28	$132,351.45	Battalion Chief
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Christopher	L.	Warden	7/11/16	$61,772.26	13.25%	$8,182.53	$79,174.01	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Juliet	L.	Harvey	6/10/18	$45,801.60	13.43%	$6,150.65	$49,906.57	Admin Assistant Lvl 3
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Jennifer	D.	Baldwin	7/15/19	$54,870.40	13.60%	$7,463.25	$49,670.99	Police Officer
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kevin	K.	Ernst	3/4/96	$84,593.60	13.64%	$11,542.62	$100,927.78	CSPPSMS V
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Timothy	J.	Korecki	8/13/18	$51,521.60	13.65%	$7,033.41	$57,164.90	Public Works Tech II – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kenneth		Ely	3/4/02	$64,563.20	13.67%	$8,825.36	$73,156.08	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Brittany	G.	Hoak	8/26/19	$48,537.22	13.69%	$6,645.74	$61,926.50	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Steven	J.	Van Alstine	11/7/16	$75,732.80	13.81%	$10,455.91	$88,270.14	Police Officer – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Christopher	S.	Buscemi	9/18/95	$94,768.13	13.82%	$13,100.06	$125,982.36	Battalion Chief
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Sean		Stewart	10/7/96	$91,998.40	13.84%	$12,731.10	$110,630.22	Senior Officer II – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Mark	J.	Hanselman	5/6/02	$82,004.83	13.96%	$11,449.76	$114,506.12	Fire Lieutenant
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Cory	A.	Pitt	7/29/13	$87,547.20	13.98%	$12,238.02	$101,849.66	Detective I – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Christopher	S.	McGlothin	10/23/12	$72,727.20	13.98%	$10,168.00	$94,161.85	Driver/Operator
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Bradley	K.	Hootman	10/21/02	$64,563.20	14.06%	$9,076.02	$73,584.38	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Matthew		Hughes	2/19/96	$90,810.72	14.17%	$12,865.59	$127,041.18	Fire – Captain – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Jonathan	J.	Lukosavich	2/11/08	$72,727.20	14.21%	$10,332.63	$99,822.77	Driver/Operator
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Brandi	M.	Lewis	1/21/20	$39,873.60	14.21%	$5,665.25	$39,934.87	Admin Assistant Lvl 1
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Lisa	M.	Lavan	9/17/18	$51,521.60	14.24%	$7,336.79	$58,228.47	Occupancy Specialist III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Dennis		Degrand	10/7/96	$104,561.60	14.33%	$14,984.98	$129,817.51	Police Staff Sgt Degreed
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Donald	E.	Howard	8/20/18	$50,294.40	14.33%	$7,208.60	$55,186.37	Public Works Tech II – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Angela	S.	Killom	2/5/18	$51,521.60	14.36%	$7,397.48	$56,951.24	Occupancy Specialist III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Douglas	A.	Egeler	4/23/12	$74,817.60	14.71%	$11,006.97	$87,579.52	Civil Engineering Spec 5
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Mark	A.	Cerilli	7/17/17	$56,763.20	14.74%	$8,368.42	$62,098.82	Water Utility Tech III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Scott	J.	Zeleny	6/3/96	$91,998.40	14.81%	$13,624.21	$108,857.11	Senior Officer II – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Patrick	E.	Sturt	4/28/03	$66,040.00	14.85%	$9,809.60	$76,289.56	Water Utility Tech IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Tracy	R.	Youell II	9/17/18	$52,599.46	15.02%	$7,898.27	$69,982.45	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Nader	F.	Jamil	8/20/12	$94,203.20	15.05%	$14,174.20	$109,851.77	Detective III – Assoc
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Michael	B.	Scherba	4/15/02	$113,276.80	15.10%	$17,106.38	$149,416.25	Police Lieutenant Degreed
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Bartholomew	K.	Bagozzi	8/12/18	$48,089.60	15.15%	$7,284.26	$44,660.16	Public Works Tech I – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Julian	D.	Gross	7/11/16	$65,467.58	15.19%	$9,942.78	$83,247.50	Driver/Operator
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Bryant		Alexander	6/15/20	$54,038.40	15.22%	$8,222.67	$34,878.17	Engineering Technician
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Matthew	J.	Waldsmith	10/5/98	$78,728.00	15.24%	$11,997.46	$94,301.55	Public Works Supv III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kenneth	R.	Richmond III	1/8/18	$57,002.40	15.30%	$8,719.12	$74,266.93	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Ronald		Ross	1/16/96	$91,998.40	15.37%	$14,136.33	$120,675.62	Senior Officer II – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Stephen	R.	Smerek Jr.	7/18/11	$64,563.20	15.47%	$9,990.32	$75,334.94	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Anissa	R.	Bowden	10/6/20	$63,315.20	15.51%	$9,822.55	$71,521.72	Contractual/Temporary
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Thomas	D.	Vinson	9/24/18	$50,294.40	15.52%	$7,806.78	$55,672.84	Public Works Tech II – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	David	E.	Ried	12/20/99	$104,561.60	15.54%	$16,251.99	$130,866.61	Police Staff Sgt Degreed
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Hope	P.	Hughes	5/13/18	$41,870.40	15.55%	$6,510.02	$46,497.46	Admin Assistant Lvl 2
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Clifford		Blackford	7/5/06	$76,763.23	15.59%	$11,964.99	$106,750.67	Driver/Operator – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Benjamin	J.	Zahn	3/13/00	$82,004.83	15.63%	$12,820.28	$110,264.34	Fire Lieutenant
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Derek	R.	Wiseley	2/3/92	$94,768.13	15.74%	$14,914.33	$142,975.96	Battalion Chief
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Zachary	T.	Cunningham	1/28/19	$56,950.40	15.80%	$8,995.47	$58,373.34	Police Officer – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Gary	W.	Shivley	11/4/12	$74,817.60	15.83%	$11,846.01	$86,113.32	Civil Engineering Spec 5
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Andrea	M.	Wright	9/21/14	$58,694.22	15.91%	$9,340.00	$64,464.07	Project Management Analys
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Rikki	A.	Stropich	7/11/16	$58,177.60	15.97%	$9,290.12	$65,186.13	Water Utility Tech IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	John	D.	Crowell	10/23/12	$68,612.54	15.98%	$10,961.03	$88,775.19	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Maurice	L.	Kelly	5/4/20	$57,324.80	16.01%	$9,177.48	$37,927.12	Engineering Technician
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Nicholas	A.	Nightwine	9/13/04	$61,443.20	16.16%	$9,928.95	$70,222.99	Water Utility Tech III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Robert		Tudor	2/14/97	$82,004.83	16.21%	$13,292.25	$118,757.26	Fire Lieutenant
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Cory	T.	Holt	11/5/18	$50,294.40	16.28%	$8,186.80	$56,366.77	Public Works Tech II – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	William		Clock	1/16/96	$104,561.60	16.36%	$17,103.16	$132,758.71	Police Staff Sgt Degreed
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Karen	L.	Channey	8/6/18	$51,521.60	16.37%	$8,436.51	$58,653.84	Public Works Tech II – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Gary	S.	Woelke	9/5/17	$74,380.80	16.61%	$12,356.62	$84,201.16	Development Srvs Insp V
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Conuetta	C.	Wright	11/28/11	$61,443.20	16.72%	$10,273.26	$67,712.54	Water Utility Tech III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Jason	S.	Nealis	7/30/07	$78,728.00	16.74%	$13,176.58	$93,786.21	CSPPSMS III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kevin		Warner	10/2/95	$101,171.20	16.78%	$16,971.53	$122,722.84	Detective III – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kirk		Hedding	2/14/97	$82,004.83	16.80%	$13,777.90	$113,542.01	Fire Lieutenant
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Andrew		Boonstra	2/19/96	$83,289.02	16.85%	$14,036.08	$123,232.28	Fire Lieutenant – Assoc
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Christopher		Chadwick	2/26/96	$64,563.20	16.91%	$10,916.61	$75,634.23	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Angelin	J.	Gentles	7/27/92	$52,291.20	17.05%	$8,917.70	$63,068.10	Admin Assistant Lvl 3
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Walter	D.	Steffe Jr.	1/8/08	$64,563.20	17.25%	$11,136.71	$75,167.75	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Erica	C.	Drake	12/8/19	$48,006.40	17.38%	$8,341.14	$53,291.61	Public Works Tech I – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Matthew	J.	Barbarich	7/11/16	$61,772.26	17.60%	$10,872.73	$84,388.98	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Jeanette	M.	Jerore-Zachariah	9/8/97	$91,998.40	17.81%	$16,385.91	$120,232.59	Senior Officer II – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Nicholas	S.	Foren	7/11/16	$61,772.26	18.01%	$11,124.09	$82,453.44	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Daniel	M.	Latimer	1/6/20	$48,006.40	18.01%	$8,646.88	$51,968.09	Public Works Tech I – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kevin	L.	Harrison	9/20/04	$64,563.20	18.04%	$11,647.32	$76,527.74	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Shane	D.	Doyon	10/15/07	$72,727.20	18.27%	$13,287.53	$102,586.30	Driver/Operator
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Janel	L.	Hansen	9/8/97	$101,171.20	18.50%	$18,719.50	$124,448.44	Detective III – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Justin	G.	Frey	2/18/18	$51,563.20	18.55%	$9,566.85	$59,612.53	Water Utility Tech II
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Matthew		McCutcheon	4/30/01	$60,049.60	18.57%	$11,148.93	$71,052.96	Public Works Tech III -IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Patrick	A.	Stacy	10/30/06	$61,422.40	18.66%	$11,460.44	$71,678.89	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Colleen		McCarthy	12/20/99	$113,276.80	18.75%	$21,235.23	$146,068.16	Police Lieutenant Degreed
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kevin		Roberson	10/4/99	$64,563.20	18.75%	$12,107.13	$77,488.83	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Timothy	J.	Irvine	5/7/18	$50,315.20	18.96%	$9,540.92	$61,259.88	FMT-AAHC IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Johnathan	P.	Fotopoulos	7/11/16	$61,772.26	19.36%	$11,959.54	$84,394.06	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Robyn	L.	Gillen	5/19/02	$91,998.40	19.50%	$17,940.60	$127,052.71	Senior Officer II – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Ammar	G.	Hamamy	3/30/15	$70,803.20	19.56%	$13,852.58	$83,568.59	Civil Engineering Spec 5
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Daniel	C.	Wooden	9/4/07	$91,332.80	19.67%	$17,968.38	$112,037.12	Public Works Supv V
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	John	T.	Maguire	4/3/06	$80,117.86	19.74%	$15,814.41	$118,044.40	Fire Lieutenant
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Karl	R.	Shuler	4/27/92	$80,537.60	19.75%	$15,903.59	$98,634.75	Civil Engineering Spec 5
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Michael		Pratt	2/19/96	$76,291.49	19.79%	$15,100.78	$107,130.61	Driver/Operator
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Darren	S.	Hickonbottom	4/29/19	$48,006.40	19.86%	$9,532.67	$55,549.27	Public Works Tech I – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Brian	G.	Rogers	11/26/01	$84,822.40	19.86%	$16,846.66	$105,728.09	Water Utility Supv III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Ala	H.	Alsaidy	5/26/20	$57,324.80	20.14%	$11,544.19	$41,687.19	Engineering Technician
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Jeremy	J.	Flack	3/13/00	$82,004.83	20.40%	$16,725.52	$118,245.54	Fire Lieutenant
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Timothy	J.	Karolak	5/6/99	$83,289.02	20.88%	$17,388.55	$122,033.30	Fire Lieutenant – Assoc
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Danielle	R.	Lalonde	2/14/97	$83,289.02	21.10%	$17,575.03	$117,742.59	Fire Lieutenant – Assoc
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Leo	A.	Susick	7/11/16	$61,772.26	21.31%	$13,162.57	$87,699.35	Firefighter
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Danny		Leyva	7/10/00	$64,563.20	21.69%	$14,003.07	$80,373.27	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kirk	A.	Pennington	3/20/06	$82,555.20	22.14%	$18,279.63	$102,196.71	Public Works Supv IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Nicholas	K.	Jaworski	6/2/14	$76,627.20	22.23%	$17,033.79	$93,874.38	Water Utility Supv IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kristopher	K.	Lussenden	3/13/00	$83,289.02	22.43%	$18,679.19	$123,327.89	Fire Lieutenant – Assoc
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Michael	J.	Lencioni	4/27/92	$101,171.20	22.87%	$23,136.34	$132,458.51	Detective III – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Robert	S.	Ashmead	12/26/18	$76,627.20	23.79%	$18,226.15	$93,920.98	Water Utility Supv IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Brian	D.	Nollar	9/27/99	$80,537.60	23.96%	$19,299.69	$100,559.21	Civil Engineering Spec 5
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Scott	J.	Reece	8/12/19	$71,219.20	24.19%	$17,227.85	$87,879.46	Water Utility Supv III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Allen		Bruck	2/19/96	$104,644.80	24.43%	$25,569.32	$141,268.56	Apparatus Master Mech – B
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Brett		Hansen	2/18/97	$101,171.20	24.54%	$24,826.24	$134,578.68	Detective III – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Tracy	A.	Pennington	4/29/02	$78,728.00	25.23%	$19,866.77	$101,523.41	Public Works Supv III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Adam		Ajam	12/20/93	$80,537.60	25.75%	$20,741.09	$102,532.34	Civil Engineering Spec 5
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Sean		McCrystal	8/2/99	$69,451.20	26.81%	$18,618.25	$88,250.46	Public Works Tech V – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Michael	J.	Culpepper	8/30/99	$86,923.20	28.41%	$24,691.65	$114,873.12	Water Utility Supv III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kevin	M.	Lancial	5/4/20	$57,324.80	29.35%	$16,825.38	$54,718.62	Engineering Technician
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Travis	J.	Conley	10/31/04	$74,859.20	29.50%	$22,086.85	$98,411.19	Public Works Supv II
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Kevin	A.	Schneider	11/9/15	$64,667.20	29.79%	$19,263.86	$83,469.28	Public Works Supv I
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Andrew	W.	Girbach	10/10/11	$62,982.40	31.28%	$19,701.59	$81,143.91	Public Works Tech IV – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Michael	A.	LaCroix	3/2/15	$80,454.40	32.55%	$26,190.44	$107,339.38	Water Utility Supv IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Mario	S.	Thompson	10/19/14	$57,179.20	32.63%	$18,660.39	$73,897.89	Public Works Tech II – IS
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Carl	A.	Emmons	6/11/17	$60,944.00	33.45%	$20,387.57	$80,627.72	Civil Engineering Spec 3
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Gregory	L.	Finch	7/23/07	$80,454.40	35.58%	$28,623.31	$110,514.19	Water Utility Supv IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	David	J.	Monroe	2/19/87	$101,171.20	37.05%	$37,485.42	$148,182.98	Detective III – Bach
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Ronald	T.	Odom	11/13/07	$64,563.20	37.07%	$23,931.33	$88,862.37	CST-PPSM IV
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Aldo		Iannelli	2/25/91	$69,451.20	38.65%	$26,845.16	$98,464.06	CST- PPSM V
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Patrick	B.	Maino	5/7/07	$78,728.00	47.32%	$37,257.81	$118,183.66	Public Works Supv III
City of Ann Arbor	48107	2020	Michael	R.	Ligon	4/29/02	$57,179.20	59.73%	$34,154.49	$91,251.61	Public Works Tech II – IS