52nd District Republican Representative Mark Ouimet Targeted For Recall
Let me just say for the record that I like 52nd District Michigan State House Republican Mark Ouimet. He’s a personable, warm and friendly man. Washtenaw County Democrats, led by Stu Dowty, then Chair, tried to derail Ouimet’s march to the State House by digging up dirt on Ouimet’s educational background (AnnArbor.com printed allegations that Ouimet’s MBA came from a diploma mill, but did not, of course, find out whether the allegations were true or not). The Washtenaw County Dems also alleged that Ouimet owed some $30,000 for per diems he’d been reimbursed for but should not have been. A later audit concluded Ouimet still owed about $15,000 to county taxpayers. Representative Ouimet promptly wrote a check for the money, unlike Ann Arbor County Commissioners and Democrats, Barbara Levin Bergman and Conan Smith, husband of Democratic State Senator Rebekah Warren and son of former Michigan gubernatorial candidate Alma Wheeler-Smith. Bergman and Conan Smith both still owe the taxpayers of Washtenaw County money for per diems they ought not to have charged taxpayers for, and both Democrats have flat out stolen the money by refusing to pay it back, unlike Republican Ouimet.
Mark Ouimet voted in favor of Michigan House 4214 that became P.A. 4, Michigan’s expanded Emergency Financial Manager Law. He also supports Governor Snyder’s proposed budget that replaces the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) for Michigan’s poor working families with a $25 per child credit. In 2009, over 800,000 Michigan families took advantage of the EITC and the credit’s loss will mean that that hundreds of thousands of families that previously got refunds will, in future, end up with a tax burden.
Snyder is proving himself a positively Dickensian character with the help of Ouimet and a Republican-controlled Michigan Senate and House of Representatives. That may change, however. I am hoping that does change, despite the fact that, as a Washtenaw County Commissioner, Republican Ouimet acted with more honesty and integrity than the two Democrats who represent Ann Arbor, one of whom (Conan Smith) came out in favor of Snyder’s expanded EFM law. Democrat Conan Smith told AnnArbor.com on March 21, 2011, shortly after Snyder signed the EFM measure into law that, “We absolutely need it. When we have cities that are in crisis, they have to get some oversight….The fact of the matter is we were not utilizing the law and it needed to be utilized.”
Eclectablog, a savvy politics blog, reported on May 3, 2011 that “on the heels of the start of the recall effort against Rep. Al Pscholka, eight additional state Representatives in Michigan are now being targeted for recall.” One of those eight is Republican Marc Ouimet. “In at least half of these districts, individuals have stepped forward and agreed to file the required paperwork to begin the recall process, a step that is soon to be completed for the remaining districts,” the blogger writes.
This is a list of the eight targeted:
District
|
Counties
|
Rep.
|
Votes
|
Signatures
|
---|---|---|---|---|
23rd
|
Wayne
|
Pat Somerville
|
15,927
|
7,451
|
24th
|
Macomb
|
Anthony Forlini
|
16,552
|
8,246
|
30th
|
Macomb
|
Jeff Farrington
|
15,732
|
7,058
|
32nd
|
Macomb/St. Clair
|
Andrea LaFontaine
|
16,101
|
7,955
|
52nd
|
Washtenaw
|
Mark Ouimet
|
21,879
|
10,546
|
55th
|
Monroe/Washtenaw
|
Rick Olson
|
17,295
|
8,169
|
56th
|
Monroe
|
Dale Zorn
|
15,582
|
7,381
|
84th
|
Huron/Tuscola
|
Kurt Damrow
|
15,190
|
7,590
|
Like in Wisconsin, where according to an April 15, 2011 story in the Chicago Sun-Times, “opponents of Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker were back at work…on recall efforts targeting Republican state senators who supported the new governor’s overhaul of public employee union rights,” Michigan efforts to recall Republican representatives will require a massive and coordinated effort. In Wisconsin, according to the Sun-Times, “organizers were using voter lists and other information to reach voters and encourage them to sign or circulate a recall petition. The strategy, is to target a different senator each day and saturate that district with calls. The phone bank is scheduled to continue seven days a week.”
A look at Ouimet’s campaign finance information reveals $500 donations from both Dr. Todd J. Roberts, former Superintendent of Ann Arbor Public Schools, and Republican Dr. Rob Steele, who ran against U.S. Representative John D. Dingell in 2010. Ouimet, like fellow suburban Ann Arbor Republican Rick Snyder, took in thousands from donors/ supporters of Ann Arbor’s Democratic mayor, John Hieftje, donors such as local developer Dennis Dahlmann, Del Dunbar who is Treasurer of the McKinley, Inc. Board of Directors, Miller Canfield attorney Paul Dimond, and Howard Cooper.
Will the Washtenaw County Democrats who voted for Ouimet at the same time they voted for Republican Rick Snyder feel enough anger, frustration and buyer’s remorse to recall the long-time Washtenaw County Commissioner-turned-state-representative? For any recall to go forward, 10,546 signatures would have to be gathered after petition language were approved.
Via email, 53rd District Democratic State Representative Jeff Irwin had to this say about the recall effort aginst his Republican colleagues: “Recall efforts are difficult and require considerable organization to be successful. I would almost always rather do something proactive, like a ballot initiative, than a recall. That’s because, when a group of people rally together to put in the massive work required to run a good campaign, it’s better to walk away with a lasting win like a permanent change in policy….I believe a recall would be unsuccessful. My judgement is that we’ve already started the 2012 campaign cycle and it would be most wise to focus on that.”
@Mark I am absolutely scandalized that Levin Bergman, Ping and Smith have not repaid this money. The county can’t file suit, of course, because the attorney works for the BOC and does their bidding. It would take a citizen, or political party to threaten a suit (or actually sue) to force the county to move against these three.
Thank you for raising the fact that two sitting Democratic county commissioners have failed to reimburse the county for overpayments that they do not contest occurred.
The last time this matter was raised publically at a County Commission meeting, Tom Wieder, during the public commentary period, lambasted County Commission Chairman Conan Smith over his failure to disgorge these overpayments. Conan replied that he had been too busy to attend to the matter,which Wieder responded that perhaps he should resign his seat if hewere unable to take care of such a task. That exchange occurred many weeks ago and Smith still has not gone through the effort of opening up his checkbook and writing the check.
Barbara Bergman told Wieder that her failure to repay the per diem and expense amounts that were found to not be properly payable by CPA audit were matters between the county and herself to which Wieder replied that this involved taxpayers’ monies and the public had a right to know her intentions.
County commissioners like Mark Ouimet, Leah Gunn, Kristin Judge and others have acted honorably in promptly reimbursing the county for amounts found not to be properly payable or questionable as soon as those amounts were confirmed. It is beyond my comprehension why Conan Smith and Barbara Bergman have failed to fork over funds to end this matter as expeditiously as possible.
There is a palpable absence of leadership on the County Commission that has allowed the per diem issue to fester for months after the CPA audit report was published due to a few commissioners that have impudently ignored their legal duties to repay these funds. Conan Smith, as chairman, should have been leading the effort to bring closure to this embarrassing episode but has been the single most flagrant scofflaw and the constant rehashing during public commentary period and in the media of his admitted delinquency has failed to motivate him to finalize payment.
If these monies are not repaid – and Jessica Ping owes another $5,000.00 – I would genuinely hope the county files a lawsuit against the recalcitrant commisioners for recoupment of these unreimbursed overpayments.
Hey there are plenty of ways to skin these critters. Recalls are scary so that’s good. Ballot initiatives mean business, but in this case there is way too much sludge coming out of Lansing to stop with only one ballot initiative. So recalling a few of those nasties might be the only solution.
In Michigan we have had a corrupt supreme court for a decade at least, so we won’t be getting any relief there–unless some smarties start a recall effort there. Golly if we had some judicious judges we might be able to ride this thing out with a few public parks left and potable water.
From FACEBOOK: “I think the basis of the recall campaign against Snyder–well, maybe not the basis, but the reason it is gaining traction–is that many people feel like he was not forthcoming during the campaign and only revealed his true agenda after he was sworn in. With only one sound-bite-ridden debate, and few hard questions from the media, there was little to go on and many moderates assumed he was a moderate, too. Shame on them for not digging deeper. Whether or not the recall succeeds, I think the recall process is a legitimate grass roots expression of democracy, and at a minimum, enough momentum could affect some policy changes from those fearful of being recalled.”—Tom Whitaker
From FACEBOOK: “I mostly agree with you Mark, and don’t think Ouimet shoud be the subject of a recall weeks after he took office. The process is mostly a waste of energy except for major crimes. However, if I were living in Wisconsin, it would be a very different story and I would be completely on board.”—Alan Goldsmith
From FACEBOOK: “What if the elected guy is a Nazi, like Hitler. Here’s a quote from MLK’s ‘Letter From Birmingham Jail’: “We should never forget that everything Adolf Hitler did in Germany was “legal” and everything the Hungarian freedom fighters did in Hungary was “illegal.” It was “illegal” to aid and comfort a Jew in Hitler’s Germany. Even so, I am sure that, had I lived in Germany at the time, I would have aided and comforted my Jewish brothers.” So immoral crimes are being committed at will and we concerned citizens are supposed to “figure out what happened [and] come back in two years or four years or six years,” C’mon man, it’s not about “cutting both ways,” it’s about doing the right thing, counselor.”—Randall Tessier
From FACEBOOK: “I am not a fan of recalls. Have never signed a recall petition and would only sign one if the elected person had committed a crime. You take your shot on election day. If you or your party can’t produce the numbers on that day, you screwed up. Not the guy who won. Figure out what happened, come back in two years or four years or six years, and win. I don’t want a constant election cycle. It cuts both ways and nothing gets done.”—Mark Hugger
I’ll clarify, that Senators and House Reps that vote for these controversial policies will get their comeuppance at their election cycle. I don’t think the recall drive will be strong for individual legislators like it was in Wisconsin.
I don’t know about this one. People like Mark Ouimet. It’s the leader-Rick Snyder- the mayhem gov, that has created this mess. The followers, those who vote for these ill-conceived ideas, will likely deal with the consequence of being lemming-like when casting their yea vote and supporting things like EFM’s expanded powers and big tax breaks for small companies only and hosing pretty much everyone else. I think Rick Snyder is more vulnerable to a successful recall drive.