The Politics of Buyer’s Remorse: Group Files Petition to Recall Gov. Rick Snyder
According to a piece published today in The Detroit News, “A group that wants to recall Republican Gov. Rick Snyder says it will file its proposed petition wording with the state of Michigan this morning. Michigan Citizens United, which last month filed paperwork to form a political action committee, announced the development Sunday on its website, firericksnyder.org.”
When Republican Governor Rick Snyder took office, he had stellar approval ratings. He coasted along during his post-primary campaign on a carpet of money (his) and support from Michigan Democrats and Independents attracted to Snyder’s say-little, feel-good 10-point plan to “reinvent” Michigan and put Michigan “back to work.” Now, some six months after the November elections, Snyder’s approval ratings are among the lowest of any of the Republican governors elected this past November. Approval ratings for most of the new Republican state leaders have fallen since November 2010, but none so quickly and as far as the approval ratings of Rick Snyder.
Snyder, who told The Detroit News in December 2010 that he had no intention of trying to target organized labor, 60 days later championed a piece of legislation that has been described by national news pundits as “fascist.” Snyder’s Emergency Financial Manager (EFM) law, HB 4214, passed in March and was signed into law. The Utne Reader published a piece titled, “Fascism comes to Michigan,” on March 16, 2011. The piece sums up Snyder’s “rule” thus far:
Snyder is like his other Tea Party Republican governors a product of crony-capitalism at its worst. After campaigning on concepts of limited government and democratic by-the-people rule, once in power Snyder, Walker and the others have almost immediately taken the unprecedented steps of trying to secure unilateral authority in the hands of the executive branch of government and granting unto themselves the ability to reward their corporate backers with the keys to the taxpayer safe.
Michigan’s Governor has become a term in the Urban Dictionary. “Rick Snyder,” according to an entry in the Urban Dictionary, “is often used to convey the sense of brutal violation – physical, emotional or any other kind.” In a sentence the term would be used something like this: “Shut up, bitch, or I’ll Rick Snyder you.”
A piece posted to the San Francisco Examiner’s web site in March 2011 by Examiner writer Dave Paulson is titled, “Fascism is Alive and Gaining Strength in America.” In his piece Paulson writes that, “public employees are just a stepping stone for the neo-fascists. The wave of Republican governors elected to office in 2010 is engaged in a full frontal attack on working Americans of all stripes. From Rick Scott in Florida to John Kasich in Ohio, from Rick Snyder in Michigan to Scott Walker in Wisconsin, backed by newly elected right-wing legislatures, these wannabe tyrants are all talking about ‘shared sacrifice’ while cutting taxes for the wealthy and then attempting to balance their budgets with spending cuts that impact everyone else.”
Even right-leaning Forbes magazine has called Snyder’s power grab just that, and writer E.D. Kain who writes a column for Forbes titled “American Times,” characterized Snyder’s Emergency Financial Manager legislation, an idea born in the Mackinac Center think tank, “one of the most sweeping, anti-democratic pieces of legislation in the country.” Since 2002, the Mackinac Center has been funded by some of the most powerful and influential right-leaning foundations in the United States. While MSNBC news analyst Rachel Maddow focused on the connection between the Koch Charitable Foundation (Texas oil billionaire funders of Wisconsin Governor Scott) and the Prince Foundation (Blackwater ties) and the Mackinac Center, the amounts given by those two foundations were minimal in comparison to other donations. While the Koch Charitable Foundation gave the Mackinac Center $10,000 between 2002-2006, the Dow Foundation forked over over $2 million dollars during the same time period, according to financial disclosure forms filed with the federal government.
According to the same financial disclosure forms, Rick Snyder’s union-busting EMF legislation was born in a think tank supported in part, during 2002-2006, by the General Motors Foundation, Inc. ($30,000) and the DaimlerChrysler Corporation Fund ($150,000).
Prior to his inauguration, naive newspaper editorialists and political pundits praised Governor Rick Snyder for not attacking Michigan’s public-sector union employees, or like Wisconsin’s Governor, trying to restrict collective bargaining on the part of public-sector unions. Reporter Nathan Bomey at AnnArbor.com posted a CliffsNotes piece based on reporting from The Detroit News in December 2010 titled, “Targeting public employees’ collective bargaining rights unlikely, Snyder says.”In that piece we read, “Michigan Gov.-elect Rick Snyder, who has indicated that he believes public employee compensation cuts are necessary to stabilize Michigan’s budget, told the Detroit News in an interview that he doesn’t think it’s necessary to restrict public employees’ collective bargaining rights.”
After Snyder’s inauguration, in a February 27, 2011 piece published in the Macomb Daily, we read: “Don’t expect the battle over the collective bargaining rights of state workers to blaze a trail through Michigan.”
Snyder told the Associated Press in late-February that, “he’s had a good dialogue with labor unions since taking office and wants to work with public employee unions to seek concessions he says are needed to balance the state budget….I respect the other governors, clearly, but as a practical matter I think we’ve already made our decision that there’s a different way of doing things.”
In short, Rick Snyder misled the public and the media. Such behavior should not have come as a surprise.
Rick Snyder’s consistently dishonest representation of his “accomplishments” in job creation and job retention as the CEO of Ann Arbor SPARK should have tipped the state and national news hounds that Snyder would not hesitate to invent facts, massage the truth, fund and push the same crony capitalism he pushed for years in Ann Arbor. However, thanks to a local newspaper willing to play ball, Rick Snyder spent years in Ann Arbor having his Ann Arbor SPARK deceptions conveniently overlooked by local reporters (one of whom went on to find work at the Mackinac Center). While Publisher of the Ann Arbor News, Laurel Champion sat on the Board of Ann Arbor SPARK. As VP at AnnArbor.com, Laurel Champion still sits on the Board of Ann Arbor SPARK, and AnnArbor.com’s “coverage” of SPARK’s “accomplishments” borders on fanzine material at times, albeit finally with a “disclaimer” that Champion sits on the Board.
In many ways, Michigan has Laurel Champion, the Ann Arbor News and AnnArbor.com to thank for Rick Snyder’s election, and his subsequent implementation of the EFM law now being attacked by national media heavy-hitters as “undemocratic,” “fascist” and “crony capitalism.” Had Snyder’s dishonest and deceptive leadership at Ann Arbor SPARK been thoroughly investigated and written about by the local press, it would have served as a trail of bread crumbs for a national media prepared to follow such leads. Instead, Snyder was able to tout bogus “accomplishments” at Ann Arbor SPARK during his campaigns instead of having to explain how he signed an Annual Report in 2008 that claimed SPARK had created/retained 12,000 jobs when there was no evidence or data to support the claim. Snyder was able to rest on his SPARK laurels despite a presentation before Ann Arbor City Council by the Chair of the LDFA that funds Ann Arbor SPARK that no jobs had been created as a result of the incubator’s “job creation” work.
The firericksnyder.org announcement says the group will try to collect at least 1.1 million signatures to be sure it has 807,000 valid ones that will withstand what is sure to be intense and well-funded scrutiny. The recall effort must collect signatures equal to 25 percent of the total votes cast for governor in the 2010 election.
Governor Snyder’s office issued a statement in response to the recall effort:
The Governor’s committed to making the tough fiscal and policy decisions that have been put off for far too long. He knew full well that it wasn’t going to be easy or a popularity contest, but he does hope that Michigan citizens will realize down the road that it will be well worth it. He’s staying focused on the job he was hired to do – turning around Michigan’s economy and making sure this is a place where we ALL can live, work, do business, play, and prosper.
A2PNotes: This comment was edited.
While i did not vote for him and deplore alot of his economic policies it is worth noting that Snyder, at least thus far, has not denied evolution or climate change or accused Obama of being a closet Muslim—ala what seems to be current Republican orthopraxy .
This makes him saner than most in that once respectable, now palinclownish, party.
However he is tending toward their reflexive homophobia, via his additional punitive cuts to Universities with same sex partners benefits, and although Ive resisted signing on to recall efforts so far, the day may come.
Without the support of some of the powerful political players in Michigan I’m afraid that I have to agree with both @Mark and @Joe that this recall effort will come up short. Mind you I don’t want to see the effort fail, and I will be disappointed if the Michigan Democratic Party and organized labor don’t jump on this grassroots effort. I am afraid, however, that because it is a grassroots effort there will be roadblocks from those who should help. We’ll have to wait and see if the petition language is approved and after that who gets on board.
I have been lurking here for quite some time, and wanted to thank you for breaking this story and writing about the various threads of the discussion, as well. I like the changes recently made to A2Politico, the additional writers, and the effort to look more closely and carefully at what our elected officials are saying and doing.
WOW! A2Politico scores again. You posted this before any of the other local sites. Moreover, your post connects some very important events that other news outlets have overlooked. I’m not prepared to conclude that because Laurel Champion is on the SPARK Board that Gov. Snyder has AnnArbor.com in his pocket, but for heaven’s sake someone at AnnArbor.com needs to tell Ms. Champion that she has no business sitting on that board, if only because there is the hint of impropriety and conflict of interest.
As a candidate Rick Snyder wouldn’t answer questions, he wouldn’t participate in debates, he wouldn’t give interviews. The Benton Harbor takeover is absolutely going to be challenged in court by officials there! I think that Snyder and some of these pols in Ann Arbor have the idea the state’s come back will be spearheaded by Ann Arbor and the Snyder policies being implemented. Our state has nowhere to go but up, but this EFM law is one of the scariest things to come out of the Republican party in years.
I think there is an excellent chance that this recall effort will succeed. If the MEA and other labor unions in Michigan throw their support behind the effort, if middle class workers get on board, I can see the group collecting 1,000,000 signatures. Just ask your Dem friends if they voted or contributed to Snyder. How many of them are willing to say so now? There is a lot of dismay at the Governor’s budget, he says it’s what he says he would do. I don’t ever remember hearing him tell voters he was going to tax the middle class so he could fund almost two billion in tax breaks for business.
Who knows if they can get enough signatures. Plenty of people are angry and dissatisfied with him.
Regarding his policies, I believe it’s going to be all about the law of unintended consequences. What parts will hold up in courts? What happens if Benton Harbor’s beachfront goes condo this year after the planning commission and others in the city have been handpicked by the guy who could potentially make millions off the deal? Hah, makes our gang look like amateurs…
To find out the Mackinac Center is calling the shots has been eyeopening, the McCarthyism of FOIAing all those professors emails has also been revealing, and now Snyder and the Mac are being watchdog by none other than Rachel Maddow. I am so pleased they FOIA’d all emails with her name on it, talk about making it personal. She’s stays quite pleasant when she trains her eye on a subject and outlines the problems involved. Thank God someone on a national level is noticiing what is happening in this state.
Yes, it’s cozy for AA.com with Snyder, but there are other news outlets in the state. How silly was it to hire a man for the job who wouldn’t answer questions?
Buyer beware.
They will never get enough valid signatures to recall Snyder.
They can also expect tremendous bureaucratic resistance from the Secretary of State and legal opposition from the Attorney General.
The anti-tax activists who got the recall election of Speaker Dillon on the ballot had problems getting several thousand signatures from a House District due to having police harassment and resistance from Terri Land’s office. That conduct resulted in state and federal lawsuits that wound up in a recall election that Dillon won hands down.
Grosse Pointe Woods engineer John Lauve attepted a gubernatorial recall a number of years ago that failed miserably.
The Snyder recall effort is doomed to failure.
Who has any real accomplishments; I like to squint and use a lot of body language to emphasize mine.
What a waste of time and energy, couldn’t these “recall” people spend their energy teaching kids to read in Detroit public schools?