The Parent Trap: The Entitled Nation Becomes The Enabled Nation

A typical day for my best friend of 40 years, who just happens to be a secretary at a public middle school, goes something like this:

Student comes in to office, needs to use the phone.

“I need the phone. I forgot my lunch.”

My friend reminds her to ask politely, “May I please use the phone Mrs. R?”

Student takes phone (without saying “thank you”) (Note: please see “The Parent Trap” on manners, March 6, 2011).

Student: “Mom. You forgot to pack my lunch. You need to bring it NOW… lunch is in 20 minutes….”

(In the background my friend is not so quietly modeling a proper scenario ‘Hi mom!  It’s me, I messed up and forgot my lunch. Can you please bring my lunch?  Thanks so much!  Love you!’)

“…No mom, you forgot.  I Need it now! Put it in my locker.”

Hangs up.

The tragic aspect of this story? In a short time, a simpering parent will stop in the Office and make some lame excuse for the child.

It’s called enabling, and it happens when kids come to expect (demand) their parents bail them out of situations that are completely the kids’ own fault.

If you are thinking this sounds vaguely familiar, has undertones of “The Parent Trap: The Entitled Nation” (March 20), you are absolutely right. This time it is The Enabled Nation. Don’t get me wrong: our kids need our help, but how can we know when to step in and help and when to let them do it themselves (heaven forbid, with some struggling or uncomfortable moments)?

Ask yourself this one question: Am I helping or enabling my child?

Helping is doing something for someone that s/he is not capable of doing himself.

Enabling is doing for someone things that s/he could and should be doing himself.

Simple, right?  Well, not always. I know sometimes I am well aware that my child can do something or handle a situation, yet I want to help out. I like to help out—the parental “you need me” emotion kicks in.  Parents need to be needed. The problem is, like the Entitled Nation, satisfying that parental need to be needed gets our kids nowhere, teaches them nothing. As if that weren’t bad enough, enabling leads to parents being slaves as opposed to leaders; our children fall into negative behaviors.

Enabled behavior leads to entitled behavior; it’s a vicious cycle.

According to Sarah Newton (youth consultant, www.ideamarketers.com), parents-as-slaves are worried about saving/rescuing their children. These parents are more concerned about short term gain and temporarily solving problems. The message they give to their children through their actions is this: “I do not trust you to do this on your own; I will always step in to save you.”

Being a slave-parent teaches children to depend unhealthily on the parent.

On the flip side, parents-as-leaders are concerned with long-term growth, development and results. They are able to let their children be prepared for and make difficult choices. The message parents-as-leaders send is this: “I trust you. I know you can handle it and you have all you need to to solve this problem.”  The results are responsible children who learn from their lessons.

Often as parents we think by stepping in that we are helping. On the contrary, not only are we enabling our kids, but we are making life much more difficult for ourselves in the years to come.

But they are so busy, our kids, you say?  Isn’t it our job to help them?

Think about this:

“When we continue to allow these (enabling) behaviors to occur, we are setting a pattern of behavior in our children that will be hard to change. We are enabling their repeated inappropriate behavior. Then we repeat the enabling pattern with the result of instilling bad habits and accepting what should be unacceptable behavior for so many years that it eventually becomes as natural to many of us as breathing. Yet all the while, a nagging feeling deep in our heart and soul tells us something is very wrong.”—www.crosswalk.com/family/parenting/when-helping-hurts-your-children

Something is very wrong. When we enable our kids we don’t permit our kids to be responsible, to try to problem solve and yes, possibly fail.

Last week, I was late running errands and I wasn’t going to be home in time to meet my seven- and nine-year-old from school. There was no way to get in touch with them. I knew I would be home within 20 minutes of when they got home. I panicked, but there was nothing I could do. My girls got home, and found an empty house (unheard of). They stayed there a few minutes, and when I still wasn’t home, they went to the neighbor who was home. Excellent!  They made up a smart plan on their own, they problem solved, and did so with flying colors.

I am not happy that I wasn’t there that day, but life is going to throw kids (and parents) curve balls.

My girls walk home from school together (four blocks). Infrequently, I walk and pick them up. I see parents who live as close or closer than I do, driving their kids. Let me qualify this a bit. If you’re on the way to work, driving the kids to school makes sense. Otherwise, yes, step away from the mini van and see what happens.

When I was in college getting my degree in Special Education (Cognitively Impaired), we learned the term “learned helplessness.” This refers to when teachers or parents do so much for kids, don’t let kids do anything for themselves, that the kids learn to be helpless. To not even try. To believe they can’t do it.

I spent a bit of time listening for enabled statements from my kids, observing some learned helplessness mostly revolving around clothes.  I realized my kids expected me to do things they are able to do.

I am, many days, an enabler. There, I’ve said it. Here are some of the things I do that my kids are completely able to do for themselves:

  • Putting out the three school-kids’ clothes (not the 14-year-old,) the night before (I like fuss-free mornings)
  • Making my kids school lunches the night before (I’m a slight control freak, and again, fuss-free mornings)
  • Making my school-aged kids’ beds while they are at school (just because they thank me)
  • Picking up way too much after them, especially after baths/showers (I hate wet towels)

I have excuses, reasons that justify to me why I do what I do. That what enablers do. This coming week, I am not going to not do the things I listed above.  Well… I may still make the beds. But lunches? No problem!!

Passing the chore baton is the first step in curing enabling. It’s tough, I know. Let’s face it.  It is easier to do things for our kids or do jobs at home that they can do, than to sit idly by, looking at the mess we are waiting for them to clean up. It is so much easier  to quickly clean up the kitchen after dinner, than to pester, remind, yell, wait and stand over them in order to get our kids to do it. Yet, we need to suck it up and slow down, graciously step aside, and, yes, lower our cleanliness standards while our kids learn.

Having jobs at home is the first step in handing your child’s life over to him/her.

You can find job lists for your child’s age here and here. (I swear the second tool isn’t a chart. We all know I steer clear of charts. See “The Parent Trap,” March 27, 2011.)

Another form of enabling older kids is in all the driving we do, taking them everywhere they think they need to go. I don’t mean lessons, practices, school functions, birthday parties, etc. Obviously, they can’t drive themselves. However, do we really need to take them everywhere they ask? No. Ask yourself this: can they walk? Can older kids take the city bus? My two older kids (12, 14) use the city bus. When my teen daughter wants to go downtown, she walks, rides her bike or takes the bus and meets a friend.

Do you find yourself wearing a path to the Middle or High School shuttling  forgotten items to your kids? Stop. They are old enough to be properly prepared for the school day. They won’t die if they miss lunch one day because they forgot it, or didn’t make it before leaving for school.

This week (and every week thereafter), you have jobs to not to,  jobs to pass on to your ever-so capable little ones. You have running around to not do. Think of the free time! All in the name of making your children more responsible.

As for me, I am going to go not make lunches, not pick up towels, not set out kids’ clothes. In my spare time I will tend to the other 57 things that are still on my “to do” list.

And perhaps, just perhaps, I’ll kick up my feet a minute and enjoy the benefits of not enabling.

20 Comments
  1. […] Made Time to Volunteer. Really. Tweet I have written about our kids being entitled, (March 20), enabled (March 27), having poor manners (March 6). Every day I am reminded how easy our kids have it, how […]

  2. Betsy says

    Oh, I’m staying tuned all right! Next week maybe he’ll be making YOU breakfast! And in a few years? Oooh, the possibilities are endless.

  3. Pearl Corners says

    Thanks for the encouragement. Not sure if its a success story yet.

    Today’s update. Same kid. Same lying in bed listening to radio. Wanders up to me 5 min before bus is scheduled to come and asks for ride to school.
    “Nope” says I.
    Today he grabbed lunch and left. Miraculously caught the bus.
    Stay tuned. Tomorrow, maybe time for breakfast, too?

  4. Betsy says

    Pearl, Boy do I love to hear success stories, and this is a great one. If you lived next door to me, you would hear me clapping and squealing with glee. I had a friend who did what you did with her kindergarten aged daughter (!) who dragged her feet every morning. One morning, mom didn’t pester, then walked her to school late then took her into the principal (a very loving man at that time) and had her (again, !) explain why she as late. I believe her daughter wasn’t late anymore… tough love for a 5 year old! Don’t know if I could do that.
    We all need reminders, we all slip into comfy parenting. I am moving towards the “no lunch making” policy as I said I would, so far I am getting items out or giving them ideas and they go from there. Not too much grumbling.
    Thanks so much for updating and sharing! We all need success stories.

  5. Pearl Corners says

    My kid got up late today. We didn’t prod him when he stayed in bed for 50 MINUTES (! ) after the alarm went off. By some miracle he made it to the school bus, but no lunch.

    Guess what? He survived.

    Thought of you!

  6. Kelly Duncan says

    @Betsy thanks! I just hate it when I talk to my friends about the work my kids do around the house and they either sigh and “wish” out loud that they could get their kids to do a bit of the work (ask them, perhaps?), or look at me like I am Cinderella’s Evil Stepmother and my poor kids must suffer. I love reading these columns, you are positive and don’t seem afraid of being a little challenging. Keep up the great writing.

  7. A2Dem says

    @Pearl when my kids cook I eat out. Not really, but I have fantasies about it. This Parent Trap column is like going to the gym on a regular basis. It’s good for you, but the pain, oh the pain. I broke it to my kids (12/15/11) that the first week of school they’ll be making their lunches the night before from healthy food choices that will be available on a shelf in the refrigerator and in the cupboard. Did anyone hear the screaming? No? There was none. “Ok,” they all said. OK?!? Why didn’t I do this sooner? Thanks Betsy.

  8. Betsy says

    A2Politico… if your kids cook, clean, mop, bring down laundry… dang! That is one healthy, “lack-of-enabling” dose going on at your house. So you are going to dig deeper, not be satisfied with what appears to be kids doing a good job. Many parents won’t do this, so awesome job. As we all know, appearances can be so deceiving.

  9. Betsy says

    lighthouse, I DO wish you luck (and really… do let me know how it goes), and I know you will be successful. Why? Because you are reading about parenting, seeing yourself and the problem and willing to give it a try. I really admire that. If only everybody would do those three things. And no problem helping your kids, just be able to see when it is beyond helping. I went to do something for one of my kids today and my husband shot me a look and asked “You’re not ENABLING… are you???”

  10. Betsy says

    Kelly, won’t it be a sweet reward when your kids grow up to be hard working, responsible adults? When those kids who you “expected too much of” can take care of themselves? How can any parent judge another for doing a good job? For making kids pull their weight and take care of their own messes? Mind boggling. I have nothing but the utmost respect for families with a strong work ethic. I wish mine was better. Kudos to you for doing your part.

  11. Betsy says

    Pearl Corners! You limit screen time! A mom after my own heart! Oh, you can all be sure I will be addressing this one soon. Dang, if we aren’t all going to whip our kids into shape yet.

  12. Betsy says

    Whoa! Had no access to my computer for the entire day, and man, do I miss out! Why was I away? Had to completely take apart a gooey, sticky, child-gunk-infested keyboard and clean it. And who got to help? You guessed it! My gunky “I better not enable them” kids. Unfortunately, they thought it was fun. Teaching to not enable doesn’t carry the same message when it is fun, I swear.
    Also, my 2 year old has decided that Mumma on the computer absolutely stinks, so I find myself sneaking away to write, only to get busted minutes later.
    Yale89, crazy Dads are always considered and much appreciated, thus the term “parents” is always used as opposed to moms. Boy, I sure wouldn’t want to do this parenting gig without the daddy at our house!
    A2Dem, some days I feel like the “crazy mom just because” but I just can’t bring myself to write about it… I have been reading a lot of parenting blogs lately, most leaving me with a feeling of “and this matters because..????”. I am looking to all of you for severe lashings if I fall into this.
    Between the unhealthy lunches and my 2 year alone, coat-less, out in the snow weeks ago as I typed, I am headed straight to a meeting with Child Protective Services, no doubt. How about making a list of things you child can choose from while packing lunch? Then my butt is covered.

  13. Yale89 says

    “Crazy mom just because….” I beg your pardon, but there are some “crazy Dad just because” people reading this column, as well. I’m one of them, but that’s another story.

  14. A2 Politico says

    A2Politico had a difficult time getting through this piece while editing. It had nothing to do with the writing. It was the shock of realizing that my own kids are somewhat enabled. Oh they clean and cook, mop and bring down the laundry, but despite these accomplishments, I’m feeling like they could benefit from a little less “help,” from A2P. @A2Dem and what’s wrong with those lunches? The Coke can maybe? @lighthouse yes, she is saying that your kids may be entitled and enabled. You will have to make the final determination, or hire a professional.

  15. Pearl Corners says

    @A2Dem….LOL! can I come over for dinner when your kids are cooking?

    The up side is if they made those lunches I bet they wouldn’t forget them at home!

  16. Pearl Corners says

    Kelly you are not alone. My kids also think that they are the ONLY ones who have to clean the bathroom. And that we are incredibly mean and over protective becuase we limit screentime.

  17. Kelly Duncan says

    A2Dem is not the only enabler reading this today I’m sure. I don’t know about most others, but few of the parents I know even ask their kids to do chores around the house. I grew up with household responsibilities, and my kids have them. They complain, and tell me that I am unreasonable for expecting them to clean the bathroom, but come on! I’m not a stay at home parent and neither is my husband. Our house is not a hotel that comes with maid service. Thank you for writing about this, because I have had the feeling for a long time of being judged by parents who don’t expect their kids to pitch in at home as if I’m expecting too much of my kids.

  18. A2Dem says

    Just so that we’re all clear I enable my children. I am an enabler. I enable. What you’re saying here is that I might want to think about stopping? Are you crazy? What would I do with all the free time? What would I talk about when I got together with other moms? If my kids made their own lunches the meals would consist of Coke, chips, leftover pizza and some cookies. We’re looking at potential child endangerment issues here, Betsy.

    On the other hand what you’re writing here makes a lot of sense, more sense than I would like to admit using my real name.

    A2Politico I’m sorry to say this new column has to go. It’s much too practical and offers reasoned logic in the place of “crazy mom just because” explanations. LOL.

  19. lighthouse says

    Are you calling *my* kids entitled and enabled? Well, honestly, after reading this entry and the Entitled Nation one I have to conclude that there is something going on. I’m not quite sure I’m ready to say that I enable my kids by helping them. Then again as you point out making excuses is a part of enabling.

    Boy what would it look like not to make lunches or to have my kids do more of the household jobs?

    I’m going to read this again and pick one suggestion. I’ll give it a try and let you know how it goes. Wish me luck.

  20. Pearl Corners says

    Learned Helplessness is my new mantra! Thanks for holding up a mirror… damn if there aren’t more wrinkles than I remember!

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.